Dear Chloe,
I am writing this letter to you because it’s a habit of mine.
I find that when I write a letter to a person instead of an concept or a history of oppression , or a convoluted backstory, I default less into the
Great Guyanese Amazonian Opera Rage and subsequent Drama Empressing that while a facet of myself I am deeply proud of not one I want to use right now.
Because your op ed upset me. in the usual ways that essays written in this vein do. They pissed me off when I was 16 years old reading them on Salon.com and the upset me when I was 24 being written about on Salon.com.
So heres the thing I don’t like I’m not a feminist but....
But I try to think of people
And it’s awfully presumptuous ( and really it’s kind of nasty and patronizing) for you to come out of your mouth the way you do about what that phrase is when you focus your feminism so solidly on the commerce producing ego stroking veins of it.
Because while I don’t like it in the way you talk about it ( and really a this point I’m not actually clear )
I also think do you or anybody who writes this kind of thing think about anybody else but the women the see as themselves ?
I think of the woman who works 65 hours a week in a job she NEEDS to survive and has racist misogynistic evil jokes told around her , or sees the liberties taken on the young girls in her circle and steps in and DOES something ,safety be damned, because watching that girl cry every day brings out something in her that can not stay silent.
I think of the 14 year old girl who stands up for the “fugly dyke bitch with the hairy legs” in her high school ( which so many young “feminists” support in theory but spend reams of paper and loads of shoe leather running away from) to the boy she likes , and the possible ire of every student she knows because she can’t exactly explain it and she’s not the type to throw middle fingers up but no one should feel like that every day of their life.
I think of the cross wearing bible thumping, GW Bush loving knitting circles that gave donations and made visits and made blankets for immigration detention centers . Because a family is a family and ones trying to stay together shouldn’t be treated the way America treats em, politics be damned.
I think of the women who post 9/11 made sure to escort Hijabbi women to grocery stores and doctors visits and put themselves in what they KNEW was bodily arm because they BELIEVED to the bottom of their souls that this , this is America and we don’t do this and until America remembered that, they were gonna make sure these women lived some SEMBLANCE of their lives knowing someone cared about their safety.
And yes I think of the woman in a bar in a class room , in any space that knows exactly what it means to be labeled a feminist, knows the stigma and knows what it can mean from social castigation to the very real threat of possible bodily harm.
And speaks /acts/does anyway.
When there is no publicity, applause, likes/pats on the head on the other side. When there isn’t the backing of your Ivy League brand ( and I’m allowed to thumb at it I went to Penn), or your Upper Middle Class college educated safety and social circles.
What about those where it means that I may not pick up the name brand but I feel it is important enough to me and my fellow woman to SPEAK?
The idea that you can take a complex and fraught and scary relationship and distill it to some armchair quarterback psychology and the patronizing “ you can do better girls” is insulting
But from the way you wrote it I’m not sure you care. You either haven’t heard a lick about me or what you have hears is not good. I’m Sydette also known as Blackamazon and I’ve been in some kerfluffles with your site mates. And by kerfluffles I mean boycotts are ongoing , chairs were thrown, and lots of stuff was/is /has been interchanged.
Renee does a better job ( and more than I’m willing to give at this point) summarizing SOME of the stuff ( the PWD thing is till in mind an epic of nasty meanness that should be spread far and wide) that went down only with YOUR website , but be a little respectful
This isn’t the first time at this rodeo for me and it probably isn’t for the women you judged . Well let’s be fair from the things you talked about you probably weren’t thinking about them because really
having those concerns about a word is for OTHER people
being in the muck and mire and the actual fear of it is for
THOSE people
( and I’m gonna taper off cause now I’m getting a lil realer than I meant to)
for the final part of my letter
May I ask ?
What will all of us saying I’m a feminist bring?
What is this feminism in your eyes and what are ten points that it brings that will fix all those pretty numbers you throw out but more importantly the lives of the people I think of.?
What will slapping a brand on my thoughts like a burning circle do for anyone I mentioned , hell what will it do for you.
I asked a whole bunch of my online friends to push this forward, black people , white people , Asian latino, PWD , queer, cis trans.
Because this is also an appeal to them.
What exactly is this shift that will happen ?
and NOT for your ability to get more op-eds, co opted gentrified rooms of your own and fuzzy feelings at hearing just one word
Because my nastiness aside ( Sorry I tried to reign most of it in but it’s a REAL issue a hurtful one dating back to before my great grandma) I do want to talk
so I’ll make a deal I’ll do one too if you ask but can you show me what screaming I’m a feminist will do for those women, my friends who will chime in , hell me
because we may not agree but you feel passionately enough to write about it so you must have some idea
Right
You’re not talking to talk so let’s talk
because if you can actual show me how it would WORK towards these things I will be the first behind shouting it out and
the funny thing is those women you’re critiquing probably would too.
All My best,
Sydette