You need to know I am a geek . I big geek , Spock was one of my first crushes, I have seen every episode of firefly twice, I readfanfic, and review entire comics cannon
NERD child.
It's not aprt of my interests I regularly blog about becuase well this blog was bout me being a woman of color and my specific experiences and
well that includes being a fen of color.
And it's RACEFAIL 2009
Now what's special on this race fail is that it's not feminism but general fandome but the principles remain the same.
We don't exist
It's only now that we knew you were here
we're so poor and irritated blah blah blah to be a part of the fandom
More importantly
seeing Star Trek with SPOCK/UHURA
so my spock crush and my little black girl linguist fantasies were both honored
but something crept up in the fandom ( an essential part of fen is that you form community fan fic smut loving you may not want to but you claim these weirdos as your own community)
People are UPST that Spock is with Uhura
now this is where my nerd child kicks into gear, as Uhura is the only one to play the vulcan lyreAND is the only person to get a smile out Spock and is IN CANNON as his mentee
and then I though about my other love
Firefly
and how Zoe while being the kicking assest to ever kick ass woman in the verse.
was often reviewed by some members of the fandom as being doting or "weakened" by her husband
and it' s become something I call
the
" Why is the black woman allowed to have a husband"
AKA as the like clockwork character assassination of any sista who is romantically attached to anyone above the accepted B-list sidekick of dubious talents
What struck me about these was the sheer mental gymnastics it takes to justify being against a relationship for this women
because while a flawed struggling romantically inclined heroine in a white woman is GREAT AND STEPS FOR WOMEN
a black woman must walk an impossible to thread line that straight up
NEVER includes her own personal fulfillment
Star Trek has been a doozy
(this post gives you the gist of it)
but if you notice the ultimate end game is that she can not regardless of what she does , make a pleasing choice that ends up with her happy
and it is especially amusing as a " trekker" I say trekkie my love for all of my geekiness knows no bounds is that
while science fiction can imagine alien furballs and spawn multiple full languages it can not imagine a future or a space where Black Women can be happy with out having to invoke whore, or in a no win double bind
but is happy to complain that there aren't enough women to introduce a character FOR THE SOUL PURPOSE OF BEING WITH SPOCK WHICH THEY CLAIM MAKES UHURA a whore NOT TO MENTION NO CANON
or taking shots at a woman's willingness to be in her relationship as " subservience"
and how much does it mirror the experience of black women IN fandom.
where in women in fandom are constantly finding things " wrong" with the representation of women but has no care to listen to the representation of BLACK WOMEN and how they perceive these things meanwhiel championing white heroines as "complex"
a black woman must walk an impossible to thread line that straight up
NEVER includes her own personal fulfillment
Star Trek has been a doozy
(this post gives you the gist of it)
but if you notice the ultimate end game is that she can not regardless of what she does , make a pleasing choice that ends up with her happy
and it is especially amusing as a " trekker" I say trekkie my love for all of my geekiness knows no bounds is that
while science fiction can imagine alien furballs and spawn multiple full languages it can not imagine a future or a space where Black Women can be happy with out having to invoke whore, or in a no win double bind
but is happy to complain that there aren't enough women to introduce a character FOR THE SOUL PURPOSE OF BEING WITH SPOCK WHICH THEY CLAIM MAKES UHURA a whore NOT TO MENTION NO CANON
or taking shots at a woman's willingness to be in her relationship as " subservience"
and how much does it mirror the experience of black women IN fandom.
where in women in fandom are constantly finding things " wrong" with the representation of women but has no care to listen to the representation of BLACK WOMEN and how they perceive these things meanwhiel championing white heroines as "complex"
and mainstream fandom spins around every ten years to tell us well it's TO HARD To deal with becuase we are so NEW ( as NEW as we were last decade)
or the constant barrage of unfounded ungrounded insults and degradations that go unanswered becuase someone jsutc an't explain why we make them so ANGRY
but where here today and we'll be here tomorrow
and yeah no only does impractical hair teh ability to wear the fuck out of a mini skirt and a love for dangly earrings ( or relaly huge boobs) not make you an amazingly big nerd
Niether does brown skin.
9 comments:
Uhura was probably my favorite member of the bridge crew, because she was the only woman who was a member of the bridge crew. I found out much later she was fourth in command (and why did that not ever ever get used in the series?).
Also, I've met Nichelle Nichols, and she's wonderful in person.
ANYway, when I saw her run into the elevator with Spock, that was one of my favorite moments in the movie - that and when she shot Kirk down. Also, when she told Spock she was assigned to Enterprise. Especially that.
And wow, the stuff described in that post is pretty gross. :( I haven't really been hunting down much Trek discussion, so I hadn't seen it. So much ass-showing fail there.
The whole mammothfail thing, it's like that whole white entitlement thing, where everything worthwhile belongs to white (cis hetero able-bodied) people, so obviously fen of color are recent visitors or tourists or something. :(
But anyway, yay for Uhura posts.
haven't got much to say, except i'm glad that foc_u and verb_noire are around.
guess i gotta go see star trek.
LISA!!!
and yeah uhura and yes it;s nots o much tehyd on't like her i could deal with it but teh sheer ackbending reasoning are WE SERIOUS HERE?!?!?!
Now you know all that Uhura bashing was all "How dare that nigger bitch be all over MY Spock (and how dare he LIKE it)!" Like I've said, folks are so used to BW being constantly represented as romantically problematic and undesirable and just plain ALONE that folks are surprised to learn we actually can get partners and committments in real fuckin' life!
Ws
see I disagree with half your statement
( only half) teh first one
It's the fact it was WELL RECIEVED AND RECIPROCATED
eminent mind blowns across entitled fandom sectors
liking spock fine
but that he would liek her BACK
oh shit
and its parallel of course iwth othe rthings but it's this simple thing wher epeople who are SO METICULOUS in fandom get so instantly sloppy
Stop hanging with the jerks and enjoy the Spock & Uhura Shippers, if you haven't already.
http://a-g-doren.livejournal.com/
BA,
Yeah, it's just so over-the-top hostile, that it's hard for me to look at it and compare it in a straightforward manner to the Harry/Hermione shippers' anger over Ron and Hermione. There's more to it, and I just don't see how that "more" doesn't come down to what you and Witchsistah are saying.
I was left wishing I'd seen more of her as an individual. But then, IT WAS AN INTRO MOVIE. And I was left wanting to see more character development for everyone besides Bones, Kirk and Spock. So.
I thought their relationship was hot, personally.
Now that I've seen it I'll be looking more into what's been going on with this, but I have to say I'm already disappointed/irritated/angry by what I expect to find by reading your response to it.
ALia you know I am already there.
LIsa I think a big part of it was that for all teh strum und drang
Whiet women do NOT identify with a Black woman if she is the only woman in a story, and she can't be pitied or hasn't shown some SUPERHUMAN damn near god like reason why whatever she has wouldn't be better "deserved" by a white woman.
It frankly happens to all WOC but each is tinged with it's own specific band of fuckeration.
As little as we see of her
we find out she's hot ( Though my love still says with NN have you seen Mirror Mirror)
she tries to handle her problems herself
she's VERY dedicated,an excellent student, a master linguist ( so good that as a cadet she unseats a veteran officer), an amazingly compassionate patient and understanding partner ( when her partner's PLANET BLOWS UP she is open and listening rather than all about how she "understands"), feisty,
( traits the original UHURA all had but for Various reasons could not express)
and she has not deserved or done enough to earn being attractive
yet she will be replaced with someone whose famous for getting soup thrown at her.
who's man defining characteristic was she was white
it's really nasty and rather than privilege it's entitlement and unplaced entitlement which is even scarier
whatshername
Have fun
and yeah t was hot
Spock turns live long and prosper into fuck off and die
and I do not wish to comment into
" Have I not beat your ass enough do wish some more"
Plus she is rather awesome
Post a Comment