Wednesday, April 09, 2008

That's All She Wrote

Never.

Never in 23 years of life did I ever think I would have to explain what fuck you meant,to grown people.

But as I sit here gazing at the black page that used to house one of the best resources in the world period.

Never as in the two years I have been doing this blog did I EVER envision the kind of heartache I would feel at a white page.

In my early post I said there was a later for explaining what I thought about the presumption that has run amok about " dialogs" "discussion" and unfettered bullshit that is in the blogosphere since wam.

But She is gone and here I am.

She is BFP .

And she was a BEACON to the concerns of POC on this internet. And she finally had enough.

She has asked that I NOT link and I will respect her wishes.

Someone should.


And I guess the little part I can do is explain fuck you.


See when I said Fuck Seal Press .

It wasn't an invitation to a dialogue. I didn't ( and still don't understand) why that was taken as anything else. I had the joy of watching three grown women . THREE mock my work , obfuscate , use derogatory and flat out racist posturing to protect themselves from critique, while using me essentially as a conduit to engage in gross bullshit self protective BUT WE"RE TRYING hemhawing.

And when it didn't work

When it was obvious that it wasn't enough that they had a press, that I had a blog I had created MYSELF for the express purpose of CREATING a place to do the POSITIVE WORK I love ( Jena 6, Southhall Black Sisters, general 23 year old happy stuff)

That MANY amazing articulate multihued diverse people wanted more , needed more and would HOLD THEM TO MORE

They simply disappeared it . To make us all crazy. To make it all just us screaming into the thin air.

Because that's exactly how this works right, slip out , demand it done your way, and expect to be served right?

And if it doesn't work your way, try and make everyone who witnessed a liar.

That's what happens in a movement/situation/press focused not on trans formative informative actually equal change.

Because when THEY say fuck you

What they mean is :

I want attention. I want to have power and if you give it to me, if you give what i want I'll mean it differently. We're not talking or demanding any change just our share. We'll work on supporting this structure LONG AS WE ARE IN IT. I am doing this to get/keep your attention, we both know if you give me the right thing , we can both USE the fact I said fuck you together to show how much the structure is wonderful and can be worthy


When I say fuck you:

No seriously I mean fuck you. I mean I find something you've done deplorable lily livered weak assed and tired and you need to pick up your grown folk underoos for you speak in my direction again. And you need to know this cause I'm gonna be looking at you sideways the entire time . Plus you come wrong at me and mine ( cause I tend reserve folks for incursions upon family) , me I might let slide, family tends to mean you want us to be in a public space near law enforcement cause depending on bad it is I may come get you. I fight fair , but I still fight.

When BFP wrote about X ( who I choose not to name cause I really can't break my computer screen) straight up fuckery. She being the incandescent human concentrated on how that complete and utter rewriting of historic precedent

ACTUALLY CONTRIBUTED TO THE HARMING OF WOMEN DOING WORK"S EFFORTS.

But once again we got to here about some FEELINGS!

There in lies the problem.

YOu see these women X, Seal Press whomever else will no doubt get upset that getting to do what they want often and without fail screws with the lives of WOC royally and repeatedly, while using them as TOTEMS ( We want you WOC *plays pokemon theme in head*)

It's the constant utter derail, pretending not to comprehend while STEALING YES STEALING .

IF not verbatim, than coopting for relevance and social cachet, weeping gathering the troops using the same in danger white woman tactics that supposedly they want to end to defend from those mean evil , ill informed always jealous

( Except I said fuck you, BFP said nothing and we're now almost guaranteed that a professor in charge of women of color TRULY BELIEVES we spend our days envying white women. HI you ever present hardheaded CLOGGED EARED ninny. I AM NOT BFP I AM ALSO NOT ALL WOMEN OF COLOR but hey you can't even follow proper citation arguments so at this point I THROW UP MY HANDS TO THE LORD)

so people can have bylines or more " diverse catalogues"

And my friends aren't digging themselves holes.



My sisters aren't GIVEN the option to swing their feelings and their privilege to suddenly disappear dissent or ScarlettO hara out of being held accountable .

My sisters don't feel safe feeling sad in rooms in fornt of stories of their families without hearing about BILL O REILLY

My sisters struggle again and again with doing beauty only to be AGAIN AGIAN AND AGIN confornted iwth ugliness for daring to dream of better worlds

Me and my sisters are mocked ridiculed for being brave enough to be what others HOPE to be until

My sister's are heartbroken, unable to see and think and feel and speak without feeling underseige


leaving nothing but blank pages

Je t'aime m'amour. Ma souer, mon couer. Je t'aime

30 comments:

Renegade Evolution said...

Grrahh. This is so wrong, so fucked up...so...gaa!

bfp is amazing, period. and i DON'T understand how it is so fucking hard to SEE that.

X? Well, I have that strap on in hell and all. And it's not like this is NEW stunt for her either.

It makes me sick.

Capsicum said...

I missed alot in the time my in-laws were in town, and was utterly heartbroken to see the blank page this morning.

I'm not sure what X is if not the Seal Press chicks, but it doesn't matter.

I know I don't comment here often, but I read every post and they all move me. I hope you never stop speaking the truth.

noemi said...

makes me very very sad this much loved Chicana's words just gone, erased.

Radfem said...

Thanks for writing this BA. It's really fucked up.

Lina said...

It's insane that bfp has quit the blogosphere and x has updated her blog with the same old shite like nowt's wrong. She's beyond disgusting. This is wrong. I'm so sad she felt this was her only course of action. I'm amazed that x hasn't even acknowledged the situation on her blog. I've not seen any evidence of her trying to put this right.
This is so wrong.

Joan Kelly said...

I am thinking this morning about BFP taking down her blog, and two things that keep coming to my mind are -

This is obviously not a new or profound thing to think or say, but I just am angered and anxious about the phenomenon of women of color writers disappearing in this particular medium. And no, I don't think it's an overreaction to call it that and see it as that, even though I only personally can think of two such women off hand (BFP and Nubian*), and one who temporarily quit, Sylvia/M.

It could be only one of those women, and still be an unbearable loss. And my resentment is kicking in, in a big way - I know men of color bloggers deal with some (not all by any stretch) of the same shit, but I never see their blogs disappearing. I don't want to see them disappearing, it's that I want to know why, when writers like BFP are writing in the first place because, as she has written, she is "women that the world requires," why is it that the only course of action that feels safe is to disappear, as a direct result of interacting with that world wherein she is required?

I am not actually asking that of BFP - I had a blog a couple of years ago about something else and one trifling jackass was enough for me to snatch it down after a few months. I just didn't want him to get to feel like he had access to me of any kind.

So I think about that dynamic, of a person using her voice, and of it feeling like a point of entry that she has to either keep constant guard of, for her own sanity, or else seal it off altogether eventually.

Versus, the use of her voice feeling like armor, like something that *increases* the ultimate volume of safety for her and others in the world.

And to hopefully be clear, I am not asking "why can't it be that BFP feels *this* other way about it and comes back??" I am saying that this is how I see things - that something that increases some people's (white, men, full list elsewhere) power is something that often is a source of threat for others. Threat you either have to build up a tolerance for, or whatever the fuck if you are to keep on in the face of it.

Because it's not actually inevitable or "understandable" that raising one's voice in this form of media should be dangerous to one's sanity or well-being. It is something that is *happening*, that is being allowed or intended, not something that is inherent to the medium.

Lastly, the other thing I was thinking of was, BFP took her blog down yesterday and it felt like a kick to the stomach to find that out. Still does. But other people have gone and come back, and while I would not presume to hope for something that may not be in another person's best interest in their own view, I certainly can hope for this being simply something that is going on right now, versus something that is permanent, the end.

*I know that I never did know you, Nubian, but I still never got over your post about how just because you might be a lesbian doesn't mean... (we want to fuck our friends, we're ever going to hit on you, etc.). Look people if you're ever going to be amazing on the internet, past or present, you are likely going to be unable to shake the patented Joan Kelly blog crush. Just a heads up.

Pink said...

I only started posting recently but have been reading, thinking, listening, reading and thinking some more. There are days when I am not sure what I am with my mixed heritage, but I am white, receive privilege as white, and live in white community. I have been working to be an ally, but today I am just sad, so very sad, that a woman, mujer muy fuerte, brownfemipower is a white page, erased. Thank you. Pink

Daomadan said...

I can't even yet express in words my sadness and anger that bfp is gone...

Radfem said...

Joan, yeah to a lot of what you said.

A lot of White feminists aren't ready for "the woman that the world requires" as they prove time and time again. I'm ashamed to ever admit I was one.


bfp is amazing. A very gifted writer who is aware of what she can do with her gift and whose joy and pain at using it, resonates with many of her readers in different ways even as it challenges many of us.

harriettheelf said...

thank you for this. I so admire and appreciate your words and your voice.

And thank you to BFP for your words. I can't get my mind around the fact that you are gone, and I will miss you and your words and your thoughts and your beautiful writing more, perhaps, than a total stranger ought to.

This entire s***storm is wretched. I agree with Lina - X is disgusting. How is it possible that she has the power to erase BFP? In a just world it would not be an option.

Octogalore said...

I hope she comes back, and I'm glad you're still here.

Tara said...

Oh no. I'm just catching up on my blog reading for the first time in over a week and just now understanding the magnitude of what's happened. And feeling sadder by the second. Thanks for posting this.

Gwen said...

I'm so annoyed and upset about this, I'm almost beyond words. How can 'X' think this is really serving feminism, to drive one of the most talented feminist bloggers away?

BFP will be sorely, sorely missed.

belledame222 said...

X is self-aggrandizing toenail fungus: she doesn't give a shit about anyone but herself, is what that is.

yeah, this is teh suck, I hope she comes back.

and Seal Press nuking that thread is just icing on the bullshit, isn't it. weak.

belledame222 said...

btw, I've noticed that clicking to links to various of her archived pages still seem to work. so, hopefully she's not planning to nuke the whole thing, just taking some time to resassess. I hope so, anyway.

Kismet said...

im new to the blog world much less the rwoc blog world--but Women of Color blog was the reason I even began to think my boundary-crossing behind HAD a voice. And ever since I found it I kept going back...until I finally started my own blog...until I finally picked up the right books and talked to the right people and really began to THINK....

in a way, finding her blog really helped me start to find my own voice...

and i never met or have yet to meet her at least...

but she drew me in...all of the rwoc sites did...but it was her first...

and someone who can do that, who can draw in strangers like that, random people from half a country away but who end up caring and and who profoundly feel the loss...well, #1. that person is amazing. #2. that person will be missed so much (and WELCOMED HOPEFUL to return) and

#3. that person deserves the respect, love, empathy and compassion returned right back in their direction--and should not have to defend herself against the people she is supposed to be able to stand in solidarity with....

i hope that makes sense. like i said, im a newbie. i make a lot of mistakes. and im still learning a lot. but i know that i am Deeply Deeply sad about the what went down---and esp. about the result, the absence of BFP.....

And much love and respect to all of the rwoc bloggers who do what they do Despite. You are appreciated.

Anonymous said...

BA,

You said it, you said it all!

I hope BFP can feel the collective love we're sending her and pain we're feeling that this could possibly have happened.

I'll call you this weekend, I need to hear your voice.

Love,

Adele

Helen said...

Mourning. That's the only word for it, for seeing something so powerful gone out of the world.

Blackamazon, I have to thank you and Brownfemipower. Because of you two personally, I now have something of a clue in matters where before I was blind and stupid. I don't know any words to describe how much that means to me. Just thank you.

Joan Kelly said...

Well, also I would just want to add - it's not my impression that BFP won't be writing anymore, so as much as I am disheartened by her blog being gone right now, I don't know that her writing is gone from the world so much as snatched from the creepy jaws of the internets at present. Which may just mean it's some place that feels safer.

Ravenmn said...

Wonderful links, BA!

I'm absolutely positive BFP will be making a huge difference in the world even without her blog. That's just the kind of woman she is. And I hope she knows she has a ton of people who have her back and want to help with whatever she turns to next. And if she comes back, that will be terrific also. What's not terrific is to have the marvelous piece of work of La Cholla get battered about by X.

Joan wrote: " How can 'X' think this is really serving feminism...."

Apparently, X believes she can serve feminism by becoming a professional writer and that her particular choice of words combined with her internet readership is sufficient. That's why a charge against X personally is a blow against feminism itself. See how that works?

OTOH, if you want to build a movement...

Joan Kelly said...

- actually it was Gwen who said that, not me...

Cassandra Says said...

Torn between feeling sad and angry here. BFP's being gone leaves a huge gaping hole in the blogosphere. Her blog was a place that felt like home for a lot of people, and it's sad to think that new people just starting to read blogs won't have that place to go to. She's going to be very much missed.

X on the other hand I wouldn't miss one bit in the unlikely event that she ever shuts the hell up. And the thing is, this isn't the first time she's done this, appropriating other people's ideas and passing them off as her own. And really, how hard is it to acknowledge where your ideas came from? Is it that difficult to admit that there are other smart bloggers out there who you might have learned something from? Is X's ego just that huge that she has to be the only one whose voice counts in her own mind?

I'm glad you're still here, BA. Don't let the assholes get you down.

Purtek said...

I can't add to what's already been sad, except to throw my hat in as yet another person who is incredibly sad about the (possibly permanent) blog loss of bfp and the sense of lost hope contained in the whole situation. I've started writing so many comments and posts, and just end up feeling like I'm thinking in circles, because I can't figure out why this should even have to be said, either.

BA, I don't think I've ever commented here before, but this, like so much of what you write, is brilliantly expressed, except I always wish it didn't have to be.

"Sudy" said...

Wordless.
Beyond fury.

Crys T said...

I agree with ravenm: whatever BFP decides to do in future, she'll be making a positive difference. I know it's selfish of me, but because all I had of her was her blog, I'm devastated by all this.

And furious because it's all happening YET AGAIN. And X and her entire crew ONCE AGAIN are failing to listen, failing to engage, failing to do anything other than whine about how mean eveyone's being to them.

While they're causing enormous anger and pain to others.

God they're fucking wretched.

Thanks so much for all your words, Blackamazon. You and all your commenters here are all that's keeping me from smashing my computer in rage.

Jennifer said...

I just want to voice my support and thank Blackamazon for these words, too. I just started reading both your blog and brownfemipower's in the last two weeks, and I'm very saddened to see hers go.

whatsername said...

I didn't know what to make of that blank page today.

Needless to say I'm pretty caught up now, thank you Blackamazon.

Fuck X.

Drakyn said...

I also miss bfp.
I didn't comment much--I'm white and not nearly as educated about this as you or bfp. And I haven't read much recently (work and depression).
But she is awesome (so much better than "decent"--which is what X is).
I hope she puts her blog back up, even just as an archive. Her blog was a excellent; an excellent resource, an excellent read, etc.
More importantly, she IS excellent, awesome, awe-inspiring, tremendously great, "wicked cool" even.

Daisy said...

Trackback

Dead Air Church: Shining Star

luisa said...

this makes me so sad.

i feel like i was taking bfp for granted. her blog was always around when i wondered over there and i hadn't commented for a while and hadn't been steppin up to defend a visionary sister when others in the blogoshere were trying to pull her down.

it is true what they say about not knowing what you have until it's gone...

there is a big, gapping hole in the blogsophere where once there was this whirlwind of a woman whose revolutionary imagination was somehow both humble and huge. she will be dearly missed.

fuck x. double fuck x.

__

stay strong BA, you are amazing and thank you for all your words.